msu library wayfinding

exploring + redefining accessibility at the msu main library

abstract

This research examines how signs and landmarks shape wayfinding in physical environments. In any navigational context, users rely on visual language—such as typeface, style, color, and imagery—to process information and make directional decisions. Effective visual design is therefore essential in creating wayfinding systems that accurately guide users through a space.

To assess the effectiveness of an existing wayfinding system, this project conducts a detailed investigation of the Michigan State University Main Library. Early findings highlight several obstacles that could be improved with more intentional design decisions. This first phase synthesizes documentation, observations, interviews, and existing literature. The results will guide the next step: identifying design interventions and developing prototypes.

Guiding Questions

This project explores the effectiveness of the MSU Main Library’s wayfinding system. The research is guided by the following questions:

  1. How do current signs and landmarks succeed—or fail—in guiding visitors toward their goals?
  2. What challenges and obstacles do users face during navigation?
  3. How can design better intervene to create a more positive, accessible navigation experience?

Step 1: Review of Existing Literature

A comprehensive review of research on interior wayfinding systems informed the project’s foundation. Significant findings include:

  • Munzer & Stahl (2011): 3D animated egocentric visualizations improve navigation more than 2D maps, especially when building layouts are complex.
  • Vilar et al. (2014): When signage contradicts environmental cues, users consistently follow the signage—showing its power in non-intuitive layouts.
  • Vilar et al. (2012): Participants navigating with horizontal, color-coded signage moved more quickly and efficiently than those using vertical signage, though differences were not statistically significant.
  • Additional sources (Kuliga et al., 2020; Meilinger et al., 2013; Gerber et al., 2015; Hölscher et al., 2006) provide context on environmental legibility, cognitive load, and individual navigation differences.

These studies establish the importance of legible signage, accessible mapping, and clear directional cues.

Step 2: Methodology
The project employed multiple qualitative and observational methods to evaluate the current wayfinding system.

2.1 Signage Survey & System Mapping

  • Every sign in the library was catalogued and analyzed.
  • All frames of the former digital interactive system were recorded.
  • Findings were compiled into large virtual maps that visually displayed system relationships and served as reference material.

2.2 Interviews & Preliminary Observations

  • Front-facing library staff were interviewed to identify common navigation problems experienced by students.
  • Observational sessions documented how users naturally moved through the space.

2.3 User Tasks & Activity Theory Framework

  • Insights from interviews informed a series of real navigation tasks.
  • Activity Theory guided task design to examine how people perform actions that support broader goals.
  • Digital ethnographic techniques captured user behaviors and decision-making.

2.4 Photo Elicitation

This method prompted deeper explanations of choices, confusion points, and underlying reasoning.

During post-task interviews, participants reviewed photos they took while navigating.

Step 3: Summary of Interview & Task Findings

User interviews and task-based observations revealed the following key insights:

  • Book Retrieval: The most challenging task was navigating the call number system.
  • Spatial Orientation: Participants struggled to distinguish between the East and West wings and had difficulty choosing the correct elevators and staircases.
  • Map Confusion: Users found the maps unclear due to missing labels, confusing color keys, and a lack of three-dimensional translation.
  • Reliance on Staff: In nearly all cases, participants asked staff for help to reach their destination.
  • Accessibility Gaps: Issues included lack of braille, visually inaccessible signage, and incorrectly labeled resource rooms.

These findings demonstrate substantial deficits in the current system’s clarity and accessibility.

Step 4: Conclusion & Proposed Design Solutions

The evaluation of the MSU Main Library’s wayfinding system reveals significant challenges that inhibit effective navigation and accessibility. To improve user experience, the following design interventions are recommended:

  1. Develop a visually unified signage system with accessible colors, typography, and iconography.
  2. Lower ceiling-mounted signage to eye level for improved visibility.
  3. Overhaul the map system with clear color keys, consistent room labels, and visual alignment with signage.
  4. Incorporate egocentric navigation cues and horizontal signage to counteract the building’s complex structure and guide users more intuitively.
  5. Install accessible guides explaining the call number system throughout the library.